Ward Identity and Gauge Corrections

Contents

Ward Identity and Gauge Corrections#

The Ward–Takahashi identity (WTI) of QED/QFD requires the hadronic current to be conserved:

\[q_\mu J^\mu = 0\]

where \(q^\mu\) is the four-momentum transfer. For free on-shell nucleons the WTI is satisfied automatically when the correct form factors are used. However, the nuclear off-shell treatment in the impulse approximation introduces violations: the nucleon inside the nucleus has a modified energy (\(E \ne \sqrt{|\boldsymbol{p}|^2+m_N^2}\)) but its vertex is still evaluated as if it were on-shell. This mismatch means \(q_\mu J^\mu \ne 0\) in general.

The Ward key selects one of four prescriptions for handling this:

None#

No correction is applied. The current returned by the nuclear model is passed to the cross-section calculation as-is.

When to use: When the nuclear model already satisfies the WTI internally (e.g. some fully relativistic models), or when you want to directly measure the size of the WTI violation as a systematic uncertainty.

Coulomb#

The longitudinal spatial component of the current along \(\boldsymbol{q}\) is fixed by the time (charge) component via the continuity equation:

\[J_L \;\to\; \frac{\omega}{|\boldsymbol{q}|}\,J^0\]

where \(\omega = q^0\) is the energy transfer and \(J_L = \hat{q}\cdot\boldsymbol{J}\) is the longitudinal component. The transverse spatial components and \(J^0\) are left unchanged.

When to use: When the time component of the current is well-constrained by the nuclear model (as in non-relativistic spectral-function calculations) and the spatial current needs to be made consistent with charge conservation. This is the most commonly used correction for quasi-elastic spectral-function models.

Weyl#

The time component is fixed by the longitudinal spatial component:

\[J^0 \;\to\; \frac{|\boldsymbol{q}|}{\omega}\,J_L\]

This is complementary to the Coulomb prescription. The spatial components are left unchanged, and \(J^0\) is derived from them.

When to use: When the spatial components of the current are considered more reliable than the time component.

Landau#

The full covariant Lorenz (Landau) gauge condition is applied. The current is projected transverse to \(q^\mu\) by subtracting its longitudinal part:

\[J^\mu \;\to\; J^\mu + \frac{J \cdot q}{Q^2}\,q^\mu\]

where \(Q^2 = -q^2 > 0\) and \(J\cdot q = J^\mu q_\mu\). This is a manifestly covariant operation; one checks directly that the result satisfies \(q_\mu J^\mu = 0\). (Equivalently, \(J^\mu \to J^\mu - (J\cdot q)\,q^\mu/q^2\).)

When to use: When a fully covariant treatment is required, for example in relativistic nuclear models where Lorentz covariance must be maintained explicitly.

Note

The choice of Ward correction does not change the physics for a model that already satisfies the WTI; it only affects the result when the WTI is violated. Comparing Ward: None with the other options therefore provides an estimate of the systematic uncertainty from nuclear off-shell effects. The default Ward: None is appropriate for a first exploration; for quantitative comparisons to data Ward: Coulomb is recommended for spectral-function models.